Monday, February 16

Some Blogging Questions

At the bottom of some people's posts, there is a line after the "post a comment" line that says "links to this post." It frequently has many links to other people's blogs, which don't even seem to be remotely related to the post written above it. What is this for? Am I missing something? Do you click on it yourself to get your post linked to it, or does it do something automatically?

And these days, there are three options for "comment form placement" (I stole that wording right out of my settings tab): 1. full page; 2. pop-up window; 3. embedded below the post. Which one do you prefer? I prefer the pop-up window for a few reasons. The embedded one makes the page too long, and I feel like I scroll forever. The full page one takes me away from the main page of your blog, and sometimes I go back to the blog to remember what I wanted to comment about, and so I like the pop-up window because I can still see your blog and go straight back to it after I close the pop-up window. What are your thoughts?

Oh, and I'm going to a little meet & greet hosted by a certain someone later this week. To quote Chandler Bing, "Could I BE any more excited?" Anyone else going?

39 people wanted to leave a comment:

deb@virginia blue said...

I have no idea how to answer your question about links...I've wondered myself MANY TIMES!

Like you, I prefer the pop-up window for comments for the same reasons.

I'm officially JEALOUS...
TOTALLY...
that you get to meet crazy Kristina in person! Wish I lived in Utah =(

Cajoh said...

At first I thought that this would be a way that I could link together my posts— but I was wrong. What I have noticed is that if you add a link in your post to another person's post your post will appear in the "Links to this post" portion of the page. I think it just gives readers a way of knowing that someone else has referenced this post in theirs and gives you a chance to see what they said as well.

I hope this is helpful,

Elisa said...

Jefe & I were going to go on a boom-chicka-wow-wow weekend... If my kids ever get over the freakin' bubonic plague... Otherwise, I will come to the meet & greet. We'll see how the stars align!

I like the pop-up one. I can position the post where I need it for my comment, and be able to look back and forth.

I did the embedded one when it was back in draft mode-- I liked it then cause no one else had it, but I decided I really hated it because you can't change users in it. It's just irritating now.

I have no idea about the links, but I really don't like it. Its confusing to me when I'm trying to find the stinkin' post a comment button and I accidentally hit someone Else's NON RELATED post... UGH.

jori-o said...

I'm as confused as you are! =)

Lara Neves said...

If you go back a couple months, you'll notice that the links at the bottom of the post are much more normal. Like actual links that someone posted in their blog.

Now, it seems like if someone clicks through from a blog sidebar it will make one of those links. It's a stupid glitch that has only been there a couple months and I really hate it. It used to be nice to see that someone had linked to a specific post of mine (and it was rare, but it did happen sometimes). Now, it's just an annoying list.

I like the pop-up for the same reasons you do. :)

Jealous you're going up for the meet and greet! Wish I could find the time to go with you. Oh well. Have fun!

Kristina P. said...

Don't get to excited. That way, when I disappoint, you won't cry.

And the links got crazy about a month ago. They are completely random now. I'm not sure what happened.

Jules AF said...

I like the pop-up one because I hate to navigate away from the main page. And I'll also be there at the meet 'n greet! Woohoo

queenbee4 said...

I am totally a pop up girl...


I wish I was going to the meeting this weekend... now I'm all sad and stuff.

Jan said...

I prefer the pop up comment box like you have. And the link to this post is something I was just curious about the other day. I don't even know how to do it. I have seen a link to the post with my name on it too. I was wondering how that worked. That is nice of them though. I have to figure it all out.

Have fun at your meet and greet. :)

Kristen said...

I like the pop-up window too!

I wish I could go to the meet & greet. i would totally BE there...lol

mCat said...

I have no answers about the links, I am just NOT that smart.
And if you are referring to the little meet and greet Saturday at the Goodwood, then YES I will be there and excited to meet everyone!

Kristen said...

I am like you, I like the pop up window for the comments for all the same reasons. Great minds think alike!

Kate said...

I like the pop ups too. Have a great week.

Jilly Bean said...

I agree with you on all points about the pop-up comment space. I also loved your fitness routine from your last post. Way to go, girl!

I played rockband for the first time on Valentines day...I loved it.

Christa said...

Is that what "links to this post" is? Links to other's blogs. I had no idea. Thanks for asking the tough questions. I can't wait to read the answers from others.

I too prefer the pop up window and for all the same reasons as you. I have kind of a short recall and have to refer back to the post when leaving comments.

I'm hoping to be able to be at the Meet & Greet. I have to find a babysitter because my husband has to run stake basketball games that day. He's on the committee which consists of the High Coucil rep and him. It's a big committee. So, there's no way he can miss, or try and run the games, play in one of his own and pay attention to 4 kids at the same time. I'm going to try really hard to be there.

Barbaloot said...

I like the pop-up window option best as well. I'm not even postive what the embedded one is...

Blogging is sometimes too confusing for me! :)

Kathy said...

I like the pop-up box. Great - now I can't remember what I did on mine! Guess I'll have to figure out the code.

I am IN for the Meet-and-Greet, and you are too - yay!! It was the opportunity to pose in a certain-someone's Snuggie that finally put me over the edge!

Kathy said...

I like the pop-up box. Great - now I can't remember what I did on mine! Guess I'll have to figure out the code.

I am IN for the Meet-and-Greet, and you are too - yay!! It was the opportunity to pose in a certain-someone's Snuggie that finally put me over the edge!

Melanie Jacobson said...

Totally pop ups for the exact reasons you mentioned.

Missy said...

The link thing scares me! WTH or WhoTH does it link too? OOOHHH!

Jessica said...

I like the pop-up window for all the same reasons. I used to not care, but now I find it anoyning when blogs don't use the pop-up window.

Just SO said...

I'm clueless on the "links to this post" dealy-o. How come you don't have that option on your posts? How did you rid yourself of it?

I'm all about the pop-up window for comments and I too will be at the meet and greet!! WOO!

Anonymous said...

I like the pop-up myself and that's what I use and as for the links, I've been asking everyone and wondering myself and I have no clue. Now within the last couple of days, I have been seeing my own links showing up and I have no idea why!

Me (aka Danielle) said...

I'm a fan of the pop-window. It makes it so much easier to leave a comment and not forget where I was. I am a 'hater' of the embedded comment box..although, it doesn't stop me from commenting!

I too am curious about the 'links to this post' I'm interested to see what you find out...

P.S. I'm planning on being at Ms. Kristinas Meet and Greet.

Dawn Parsons Smith said...

I didn't even know you could have options for the comment box to pop up (duhmmy here)...

I am glad that you wrote about this!

Have fun at the meet and greet!!!

Tiffany said...

I am so with you on lovin the pop up. I think we should make everyone switch, or boycott their blogs.

rich and steph said...

I had no clue about the pop ups until I started seeing them on others blogs. I have no clue about the links to. Now I gotta figure out how to do the pop ups!!

Momo Fali said...

I like the pop up window too. It makes it convenient when the kids interrupt me a thousand times and I need to go back and read something again.

Hepburn Hilton said...

Me to! Pop- up for the same reasons.

I've been wondering about the link to the blogpost thing as well... I ahve this on my blog simply because it's a part of my layout template. I don't get it- If you figuer it out let me know!

:o)

Sabrina said...

Fun! You guys are going to have so much fun! Wish i could go! :)

Kimberly Vanderhorst said...

Definitely love the pop-up window - wish I knew how to make it happen on my site.

As for the links to post, a lot of things are going screwy because of those blogrolls that show the most recent post on a given person's blog. So the link mentioned in the link list is often just the automatic link created by someone's blog roll widget. Does that make sense? Probably not...I'm tired... =P

Dione said...

Hi Erin - I'm thinking of going to the meet and greet but I only know Kristina (and Ramona if she is going) so I thought I'd get to know you and some of the other bloggers. I've enjoyed reading your blog and look forward to reading some more!

Lee said...

I have no idea what that links thing is! I've always wondered myself! Let me know if you get an answer.

Sara @ Our Best Bites said...

Okay, I know exactly what you're talking about. It is SO annoying. It used to be that if someone linked our blog in a post it showed up. Great. Now, we get like 30+ links showing up there and none of them have anything to do with our post. And on our blog at least, most of the "links" it's showing often come from one blog. Like it will just show 20 something different posts of hers. I think whoever mentioned the widget thing is onto something, that's the only thing I could think of. Like if a blog has one of those things that automatically shows updates on their favorite blogs, it will show it as a link. I dunno, I've been trying to figure it out as well.

Heidi said...

I got nothing. Except that I wish I could be there for the meet and greet!

Mary said...

I like the pop-up window, b/c I am always playing catch up and hate using the back button to get back to the rest of the posts.

rychelle said...

you're going to the meet n greet?!? i'm so jealous!

Helene said...

I don't know anything about the links, though I have noticed that one some posts written by others.

I hadn't even thought about the comment window but now that you listed your reasons for liking the pop-up window, I have to agree. I'm gonna change mine to the pop-up window!

Brooke said...

I love the pop-ups, too. I don't know about anything else.