Friday, July 1

On Judging

Story #1:

My sister lives in a very small town. Everyone knows everyone else. That can definitely be a good thing and a bad thing, as I'm sure you can imagine. Everyone knows who to call when they need help (which is, very often, my sister) and everyone knows who to avoid...

Enter Marie (not her real name). Marie is a self-professed jack-Mormon. (Jack-Mormon is a nickname some people use to describe someone of my faith who doesn't usually go to church and doesn't necessarily abide by the rules of the church.) Marie drinks, she used to smoke but finally kicked the habit, she loves to cuss, and because of some of these reasons, some members of the community avoid her.

And my sister said she is one of the kindest, most selfless, giving people she has ever met. My sister's husband recently had an accident at work that required surgery. Some friends and family called to see how he was doing, and would end the phone calls with, "Well, if there's anything I can do..." (These platitudes felt hollow to my sister.) Marie, however, said, "I will take your kids while your husband is in surgery and I will be making you dinner too." She gave my sister the true support and friendship she needed at a difficult time.

Marie always does things like this. She is currently doing a fundraiser, hoping to raise a thousand dollars to donate to a local organization that gives monetary and medical aid to local residents in need.

I want to be more like Marie. It's really sad that people are unwilling to get to know her because of their discomfort since she is different from them.


Story #2

We have a lovely family who lives in our neighborhood. The husband has a series of ailments which render him severely disabled. He is a great man. On good days, he can walk down the street and back. On bad days, he can't leave his bed. He comes to church when he can. He spends as much time with his children as he can. He can't do much else.

The wife runs the household. She does virtually everything, from raising their five children, to running the in-home business, to cooking and cleaning and chauffering everyone around. She is also going to school to earn her degree so she can get a job doing something she loves. She and her husband never complain, even when things are really rough. I have nothing but praise and love for this family. They are doing the very best they can with the circumstances they have been given.

Two days ago, this dear, sweet family received a two page letter in the mail. This anonymous letter told told them that their yard is a disgrace to the neighborhood. It said that they shouldn't have built a house there if they weren't going to keep the yard up. It said that lots of people have health problems, and they are still able to have nice yards. Then it got personal, calling them "users" (because some members of the church did some yard work last year and they didn't "keep it up") and that they are lazy and bad examples to their children. It ended by calling them "the worm in the apple that needs to be cut out" of the neighborhood.

My heart bleeds for this family. Someone just added insult to injury. What happened to "love thy neighbor"? Why do people feel the need to judge, and to spew forth ugliness in the world? What makes any one of us any better than anyone else?

Nothing. We are all equal in God's eyes.

Please, please don't judge others. We never know their circumstances. Even if we think we do, we don't.

(P.S. Their yard is just fine. I would move next door to them in a heartbeat, and I see nothing wrong with their yard at all.)

22 people wanted to leave a comment:

Christa said...

I think we don't need to think of kindness & the way we treat others as "treat them the way you would like to be treated". I think we need to think of treating them the way Jesus Christ would. We would certainly all be nicer to each other if we did.

Christa said...

I hope that first comment makes sense! :)

Ruth said...

Wow is all I can say. Marie and I would be great friends. Because of my neighbors and their judgments about me, the only person that speaks to me is the inactive, smoker in the neighborhood. She has a good heart. She works hard and takes care of her ailing mom. The same neighbors have passed judgment on her too. I call her my neighborfriend.

Stephanie said...

Both of these stories make me sad. Really sad. I really, really hope I can do better than that.

Wonder Woman said...

Thank you for sharing these stories. One of my all-time favorite quotes is Elder Ashton's quote on charity. He mentions not judging others and giving the benefit of the doubt as aspects of charity. I love the quote.

My heart breaks for the family who received the letter, and for the sender. I can't help but wonder what kinds of insecurities a person must have to send something like that, and what lead to those insecurities.

Karen E. said...

Seriously? So sad. I'm reminded of the phrase "Charity seeketh not her own." A friend once interpreted this as meaning we should direct charity purposely toward those who are not like us. I wish I were better at this myself (although I don't think I would go so far as to send an anonymous letter to someone about their yard--those poor people).

Christine said...

I started feeling judgmental toward a man in my ward once we were friends on facebook, because I noticed that he tended to swear pretty regularly.
But then one day I realized that this man is so helpful and selfless toward me and my family. He comes over and does little repairs that my husband can't do and always fixes our computers for free. (you can probably guess who I mean Erin!)
I was truly humbled to realize that. How dare I think badly of ANYONE when I'm so imperfect in so many ways, and when someone like him serves the way Christ would serve, which matters infinitely more.

Amy said...

Wow. I cannot believe the heartlessness of some people. Charity really is disappearing in the land. It breaks my heart. What heartbreak the person who sent the note must be feeling to be so malicious and without a heart (and here I go passing judgement). Sigh. It must just be one of those things you just have to keep trying to get away from for the rest of your life. How sad for those people, and what a lesson for the rest of us.

Rachel Sue said...

Have you ever read Flipped? You should. Very similar situation. (And a good book besides). Honestly, some people just need to get over themselves. I think so many people forget the "walk a mile in their shoes" adage and assume that because someone lives in the same neighborhood, demographic, that they must come from the same circumstances. Which, if you have lived anywhere at all, you know is never the case.

It's this kind of thing that gets me really riled up. If you couldn't tell.

CB said...

I love this post because it happens all the time.

We can never know another's circumstances until we walk in their shoes.

LisAway said...

Judging is dumb. But judging and then acting on the uncharitable thoughts and feelings it creates is just terrible. Thanks for the reminder.

mCat said...

I want to say 'unbelievable" but sadly, I can believe it.

My heart hurts for that family. Hoping their faith in the ultimte goodness in MOST people will overcome this experience

FireMom said...

Anonymous letters? What is this: 8th grade? Sigh.

I will never understand why people think that doing things like this is a good idea. Or why avoiding kind-hearted people is acceptable.

Julie P said...

Amen.

Jessica G. said...

I'm totally with FireMom on this one.
My brother joined the Air Force right out of high school instead of going on a mission. His testimony wasn't strong at that time and he and his girlfriend hadn't exactly stayed on the straight and narrow. So he joined the military. At his first base, he went to the local ward, so terribly lonely and seeking people who shared his beliefs. One sister in the ward found out he hadn't served a mission and basically ostracized him from the ward. It took years for him to come back to church after that experience.

The Yoder's Five said...

People can be so DUMB and mean--even members of our church. I'm surprised at how many of them still think less of others in the neighborhood if they're not white and Mormon. Seriously!!!!

I was so mad about that letter, too. That family is amazing and I'm glad to know them.

That Girl said...

I ... can't believe it. My mouth LITERALLY dropped open.

I can't imagine how much that woman must be hurting. Now she'll probably question everyone she sees, thinking, "are they the one?!"

I feel awfully sorry for the person who wrote the letter, too. How awful it must be to carry around so much anger and bitterness.

Lara Neves said...

Wow. I will never understand why people would go to such lengths as to send a letter full of vitriol and hate to someone who is doing their best. Actually, even to someone who may NOT be doing their best. What purpose does that serve.

Thanks for these stories. They are eye-opening and help me remember to be better than that.

Anne-Marie said...

This was a great post, Erin. I so agree. I've been the inactive in a neighborhood before and you really just don't get to know your neighbors.

The Kooky Queen--Rachel said...

OH MY GOODNESS!!! There is a little spot in a really hot place reserved for whomever wrote that letter. Evil, really evil MEAN!

Jessica said...

Thanks for the reminder. I cna get judgemental and don't always remember that others are doing the best they can.

It's stories like these that make me wonder how these people can call themselves Christian becuase that is NOT what Christ would do.

Melanie Jacobson said...

We once got a letter like that. It was brutal. Shame on the people who send them.